Where’s your fish bowl?


Hat tip Stormhoek

Barry Schwartz at TED on the Paradox of Choice. Great speaker, but that is no reason to inflict those shorts on us.

Print this post using HP Tabblo Print Toolkit

8 comments for this post.

  1. Comment from James Tutt on November 28th, 2008 :

    I don’t buy this. While he can poke holes in the bountiful choices we have open to us, the alternative is too grotesque to contemplate. The choices never go away or become fewer in number. Either we make them ourselves or we hand over our freedom to choose to someone else to make them for us. Power then becomes centralised and such a concentration of power will always attract megalomaniacs, dictators, idealogues and, frankly, corrupt bureacrats who will favour their own or the highest bidder. The repeated failure of socialism in the last century, sadly for the people involved, proves this.

    Highly distributed choice is a bulwark to defend, amongst other freedoms, democracy. It is no accident that the countries with the freest markets
    have the highest participation in free elections.

    Apart from some low-level whining about jeans shopping and salad dressing, he fails to cogently argue why having these choices is so bad.

    Ultimately this comes across as a manifesto for lowered ambitions and for people to know their place. I’ve seen far better TED videos I’m afraid.

  2. Comment from David Brain on November 28th, 2008 :

    Yes I agree restricted choice is no philosophy for organising life that I would like to live under. That said, the guy comes at this from a mmore psychological point of view I thought and that is indeed valid. The point of posting it was that for those of us in communications I think it serves as a real reminder that people often find choice stressful and options difficult. The example of the take-up of pensions he used was a good one. Sometimes our job is simplifying, differentiating and finding shorthands rather than listing attributes and benefits as so many brand seem still to do.

  3. Pingback from Setting Goals and Expectations « Blogging Me Blogging You on November 29th, 2008 :

    […] First up, the inimitable David Brain posts an excellent talk from TED by Barry Schwartz, Dorwin Cartwright Professor of Social Theory and Social Action at Swarthmore College. Barry talks about how the sheer volume and breadth of choices available to us have only served to heighten our expectations to an unreasonable level - to the point where it is almost impossible to be delighted any more. The best you can hope for is for your expectations to be reached. […]

  4. Comment from steve clayton on November 29th, 2008 :

    BA T5 lounge PC’s don’t have flash enabled. pants!
    oh well, back to the bar….

  5. Pingback from " » Decisions, Decisions…" from PR Girlz on December 3rd, 2008 :

    […] A few days ago, I read Ed Lee’s post about Setting Goals and Expectations. He links to this video of Barry Schwartz speaking at TED about the Paradox of Choice. Considering my own life lately, this presentation was quite thought-provoking, and left me pondering the choices we make and how we feel about those decisions once we made them. […]

  6. Comment from Tenders on September 5th, 2009 :

    Отличное наполнение блога, есть что почитать интересного, спс

  7. Comment from NejikFans on September 5th, 2009 :

    Согласен, полезная информация

  8. Comment from Tamada on September 15th, 2009 :

    Посоветовали мне этот блог, и видно что незря, есть все что я хотел найти.

Leave a Comment


Back to top